In With The Old: The Rebirth of HubSpot
A totemic co-founder unexpectedly returns as CEO. Can he fix the cracks within HubSpot's formerly industry leading go-to-market strategy?
It could be the most consequential leadership change of the AI era. No, I'm not talking about Jensen Huang leaving Nvidia. That has major implications for data centre financing and the longevity of the AI bubble. Outside Wall Street, the major software platforms are more significant. That's why the return of Brian Halligan as CEO of HubSpot is far more relevant to marketing. AI is already embedded in everyday marketing workflows, both for content production and increasingly also for data management. No one is going back to the era when every last piece of content needed to be drafted manually. For marketers, the time and cost savings are too great.
New Competitors
The real question is how generative AI technology is used and in which platforms. That's a battle which the traditional marketing automation platforms feel like they're losing. Sure, they retain their role in content delivery, but Claude and ChatGPT are rapidly becoming the nerve centre of the marketing content engine. For HubSpot in particular, that's a serious threat. Few enterprises will ditch their expensive Salesforce licenses for a vibe-coded alternative. Never mind the security and compliance risks, enterprise CRM systems are embedded in too many business critical go to market workflows.
Ditching HubSpot for a basic email service provider is a realistic option for many small businesses. HubSpot started out as one SMB marketing automation platform among many. Its focus on inbound marketing gave it a successful niche. The addition of CRM capabilities turned it into an industry standard. Over time, it has become a leading Salesforce competitor within SMB sales and service teams as well. It's a startlingly successful product market transition, which deserves to be recognised as one of the most successful rebranding exercises of the SaaS era.
Trouble is, many SMBs only have very basic CRM needs. That's how HubSpot was able to capture the market initially, by becoming the best free option. The convenience of an all-in-one sales and marketing tool will keep them on HubSpot, but only so long as the system fulfils their marketing needs. A new generation of AI-driven marketing automation platforms are emerging to target HubSpot users who want something which does the manual work for them. The likes of Conversion and Phave still have a long way to go, but they pose the biggest threat to HubSpot's market position for some time. Combine those platforms with Claude-powered pipeline tracking reports, and suddenly businesses don't need HubSpot anymore.
An Unfocused Roadmap
The risk would be minimised if HubSpot was a stable product with predictable low pricing. Increasingly, it is not. The company has spent the last five years pushing upmarket. Yet it feels like HubSpot's much touted enterprise push has focused only on an ever increasing number of new features with little attention given to deepening existing product areas. Basic capabilities such as lead capture, campaigns and reporting have seen lots of new bells and whistles added, but are missing key customisation capabilities widely used in Marketo or Salesforce. Consequently, the product is no longer an ideal fit for either small startups or rapidly scaling growth firms. It works OK for everyone, but not well enough to be a strong fit.
A disjointed product roadmap is not a terminal problem. Plenty of larger competitors also struggle with a lack of focus. However, AI has given customers a reason to search for new CRM and marketing automation platforms. The HubSpot product team has reacted well to the AI threat, releasing a broad portfolio of new AI agents that can support many go to market tasks across sales, marketing and customer service. Discoverability is a concern, and there are too many for most business users to keep up with. As a result, AI product features have not been matched by user adoption, because those agents merely have been bolted onto the existing UI.
The Need for Predictability
To pay for all these extra AI features, HubSpot has introduced a usage based component to pricing. Every subscription gets a bundle of free AI credits, with optional top-ups. Seat based user licensing still continues though. There are several different variations to the pricing scheme. One experiment in the Nordics even consumes credits for non-AI usage such as email sends and workflow actions. This is being expanded to new customers in all of EMEA this quarter, which is great news for agencies selling product audits. It's not so good news for customers with a lot of campaigns in market.
As Salesforce have also discovered, credit based pricing limits product uptake. Businesses want predictable technology costs and are afraid of going over usage limits for core business functionality. No one wants to risk finance refusing extra budget to cover overspends. HubSpot's outgoing CFO even admitted as much in their earnings call two weeks ago, saying that the Nordics pricing experiment had reduced average selling prices (and presumably revenue). Although HubSpot have been quick to introduce usage limits and credit caps to help mitigate concerns.
More scalable pricing would help win back customers. Complaints about the high cost of the professional tier abound on social media. In the long term, though, a more focused product narrative would explain why usage based pricing is needed. The first step is to develop a coherent AI focused product strategy that allows marketers to experiment with new agentic go to market models, while still executing business as usual. The product foundations are already in place. It just needs deeper context, clearer packaging and more coherent user journeys. Customers don't know what HubSpot can do, and it feels like HubSpot doesn't know what their customers want.
What Happened to Loop Marketing?
Last year, HubSpot launched the concept of Loop Marketing to explain how marketers should run their marketing programs in the AI age. The concept of highly targeted, rapidly developed, adaptive campaigns has been taken up as part of the agentic marketing trend. It does not seem to appear anywhere in HubSpot's own product thinking though. With vibe coding back on the agenda, and new AI competitors launching weekly that's a problem. AI native firms such as Clay and Attio have stolen the thought leadership spotlight. That hype is slowly being translated into market share.
In the AI startup world, HubSpot is seen as legacy. A viewpoint which is being reflected in customer acquisition at the lower end of the market, which was described as 'soft' in HubSpot's latest earnings call. For the first time, they are not the obvious go to market tool for new technology startups. Nor are they seen as a migration candidate for smaller enterprises looking to streamline a complex Marketo or Eloqua setup. They're stuck in the middle. Hence, why new leadership is required. Someone needs to bridge the gap between everyday campaign sprawl and the AI dream being pitched on LinkedIn. HubSpot is better placed than most to do it.
In Brief
HubSpot in Claude
If you're the kind of person who does everything through Claude, then HubSpot's latest integration is for you. You can now work from within the HubSpot product UX directly within Claude. It's part of a new Claude feature that was announced last week.
Operationalising ABM in the Real World: Your Step-by-Step Guide
Finding it difficult to navigate the complexities of ABM. A new eGuide from CRMT Digital cuts through ABM hype, explaining how to implement and run an ABM program in practical terms. Boost ROI with practical approaches to account-based targeting, personalisation and engagement.
Marketing Operations Roadmap Matrix
A Marketing Operations Roadmap is an essential strategic tool that aligns marketing priorities with your overall business goals. Any roadmap begins with understanding where your marketing organisation is right now, and then defining where you want to get to. This free Marketing Operations Roadmap Matrix from CRMT Digital allows you to do exactly that.